Reflecting on reverse mortgage spokespersons, marketing methods

As major players in the mortgage market make big bets on a future boom in reverse mortgages, it's worth looking at changes over the years in how they are marketed. 

Following developments in regulation, companies are more limited in how they can advertise to Americans. One of the main methods in past decades was to gain trust through a famous actor of the time via TV commercials. 

These methods are starting to see a shift, said Wayne Stanley, president and CEO of marketing firm Bowe Digital, which specializes in the land title insurance industry. 

Because of greater scrutiny from regulators like the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, marketing these loans on television has become less common. 

Back in 2016, the CFPB ordered American Advisors Group, Reverse Mortgage Solutions and Aegean Financial to "cease deceptive advertising practices, implement systems to ensure they are complying with all laws, and pay penalties." 

A study done by the Bureau in 2015 analyzed reactions to reverse mortgage advertisements and concluded that the ads of the time tended to confuse consumers, causing concern. 

"The CFPB is concerned that advertisements may lead some older homeowners to believe that reverse mortgages are a risk-free government program or benefit. While the federal insurance for reverse mortgages provides some important protections for borrowers, they are secured loans and homeowners can lose their home if they fail to meet the loan terms," the CFPB concluded. 

While differing federal and state laws govern how reverse mortgages can be advertised, it is always illegal for any party to make deceptive claims. The most influential federal laws on the matter are the MAPs rule, which made deceptive claims illegal, the Truth in Lending Act and the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010.

Many companies have shifted to a direct education approach in their marketing, explaining the benefits and risks through paper mail and through email to more technology-savvy homeowners, Stanley said. 

He said it's likely a mix between the conditions of the current market and the direct approach that helps to motivate homeowners to pursue the product. Because of the state of the economy, it's a lot easier for some consumers to understand the benefits of a reverse mortgage, Stanley said.

"There are many more that might be ready to make that leap for that type of product, so they don't have to use celebrity types to get that. The money speaks for itself," Stanley said. 

Following the 2008 financial crisis when many saw large chunks of their future disappear, the Boomer and Gen X generations are more skeptical and tend to do more homework on loans they're considering, he said. Because of that shift, direct education is more valuable to them than a celebrity face. 

"The regulatory eye on some of this has forced them to be more upfront about the benefit," Stanley told National Mortgage News. "I think that it's opened it up to people that previously may have not given it a second look. Now that they're even giving a couple of bullet points of more information or education has been way more helpful than before… It feels a little more secure than I think it did in the past."

Here's a look at some of the famous faces from television that have promoted reverse mortgages:

Tom Selleck

Coldwell Banker, American Advisors Group, Finance of America
Finance of America Info Kit Video, 2024

The legendary actor became a household name, and gained the trust of older generations of Americans, from his starring role in "Magnum, P.I." and appearances in "Blue Bloods." 

In 2012, Selleck appeared in a homeownership campaign for Coldwell Banker. He later became a longtime spokesperson for the reserve mortgage lender American Advisors Group. He starred in commercials explaining the benefits, but none of the risks, of reverse mortgage loans to older Americans. This drew controversy from people who felt the loans were scams. 

When the partnership began in 2016 after a search to replace the late Sen. Fred Thompson, AAG released a statement heralding its selection of Selleck as its national spokesperson. 

"Our research reinforced the widespread recognition and respect that Tom Selleck has garnered among Americans and crosses generations," AAG said. 

Selleck gained a separate reputation from his appearances in several of the company's TV commercials, with many people online saying his words shouldn't be trusted.

One user on Reddit responded to a post resurfacing one of Selleck's commercials, saying "My all time most hated commercial. From Magnum PI to Blue Bloods - doesn't this guy have enough money? No! Now he has to take advantage of poor and old people." 

In 2021, the CFPB accused AAG of deceptively marketing the product to consumers by using inflated home estimates. The firm also came under fire for violating a previous 2016 administrative consent order from the Bureau, filed after AAG marketed statements promising consumers they wouldn't lose their homes. The company was required to pay over $1 million in civil penalties and change its advertising strategies. 

AAG was purchased by Finance of America in 2022 – also the year Selleck last appeared in a commercial, until recently – and later was consolidated with Finance of America Reverse under one brand. The parent company, which exited forward lender prior to the deal, became one of the largest providers of reverse mortgages following the acquisition. 

Finance of America, after a rocky few quarters, remained in the red during the second quarter but moved closer to profitability. After the firm received a second delisting notice from the NYSE in February, executives touted their success in using a reverse stock split to resolve the threat.

The company also reported that Selleck will be returning. Assuming the deal with the actor as part of the tie to AAG is part of the plan to leverage its new assets and continue its appeal to senior borrowers, said FOA President Kristen Sieffert during its second-quarter earnings presentation. 

The company launched new ads with Selleck and multimedia advertising efforts following the consolidation in hopes of increasing its market visibility and customer recognition. Sieffert said the marketing strategy for FOA's retail lending division was revised and the company expects to see outsized returns from discontinuing less fruitful strategies. 

FOA posted a new infomercial featuring Selleck to YouTube last month. The company said at the time that its sentiment analysis of reverse mortgage media coverage has been steadily improving and coverage of the company itself skews "neutral to positive," according to HousingWire. 

In the supplemental commentary on its second-quarter results, FOA said July "is the highest funding month and highest submission month" since its acquisition of AAG, and recent mortgage rate declines are expected to positively impact third-quarter results, according to HousingWire.

Sieffert discussed efforts the company is making to expand awareness of its products across the total available market.

"We continue to invest in digital technologies that capitalize on growth opportunities and create tailored experiences for our customers," Sieffert said. 

Sen. Fred Thompson

American Advisors Group
American Advisors Group Commercial

The late actor and former Tennessee senator was AAG's spokesperson before Selleck from 2010 to his death in 2015. He appeared as an actor in several episodes of "Law & Order" and its spinoff shows. Thompson also ran for the presidency in 2008 as a Republican candidate.

Thompson's notoriety in the political sphere, especially to Americans who aligned with his beliefs, made him an influential face in the marketing world for reverse loans. 

Henry Winkler

One Reverse Mortgage by QuickenLoans
One Reverse Mortgage Commercial

Best known for his role as Arthur "The Fonz" Fonzarelli in the mid-1970s-80s show "Happy Days," Winkler was often seen in commercials for One Reverse Mortgage, Quicken Loans' reverse lending arm. 

He first appeared in commercials for the firm in 2012 and made his final appearance in the ads in 2018.

Robert Wagner

Urban Financial Group, Senior Lending Network
Senior Lending Network Commercial

The small-screen star is known by older Americans for his roles in "It Takes a Thief" in the late 1960s and "Hart to Hart" in the early 1980s. Wagner may also be recognizable to younger audiences for the "Austin Powers" film franchise and stints on "Two and A Half Men" and "NCIS." 

He was also a spokesperson for Urban Financial Group and formerly represented the now-defunct Senior Lending Network. He appeared in three commercials from 2012 to 2013.

Jerry Orbach

Senior Lending Network
The late Tony award-winning actor was also well-known for his role as Detective Lennie Briscoe on "Law & Order" in the 1990s. Orbach was a spokesperson for Senior Lending Network, like Wagner, until his death in 2004, according to All Reverse Mortgage Inc. The company went under in 2009. 
MORE FROM NATIONAL MORTGAGE NEWS